READER'S SUBMISSION EVALUATION FORM/투고논문심사양식

The Yeats Journal of Korea
Editorial Secretary: Department of English, Pusan University, Busan, 609-735, Korea; E-mail: iyoon@pusan.ac.kr
1) The Title of the Submission:
2) Result of Evaluation (Please check one):
Publishable as it is ( )
Publishable with revisions ( )
Reevaluation after revisions ( )
Rejected ( )
3) Evaluations:
Please evaluate the eight items below by putting down A, B, or C, and provide the Editor with the basis of your evaluation in the Statement below that is no more than two pages long.
Evaluations A   B   C
1) Originality of the subject; Creativity of methodology
2) Clarity of thesis
3) Suitability of citations and supports
4) Connectivity between paragraphs
5) Proper structure and density of the submission
6) Clarity of sentences
7) Appropriateness of form in the submission
8) Clarity of Abstract
Please put down your overall Evaluation, checking one of these ratings: Publishable as it is; Publishable with revisions; Reevaluation after revisions; Rejected.
Date of Evaluation:
Name of Reader:
Reader's Institution, E-mail, and Phone:
Statement (Please use a separate sheet if you need more space.)

한국예이츠학회 심사 양식
한국예이츠학회
(우편번호 609-735) 부산광역시 금정구 부산대학로 63번길 2(장전동) 부산대학교 영어영문학과;         E-mail: iyoon@pusan.ac.kr
논문심사 결과보고서
논문제목:

심사결과: 게재 가 ( ), 수정 후 게재 ( ), 수정 후 재심사( ), 게재 불가 ( )

아래 항목들에 대하여 A, B, C 등급을 표시하고, 심사자의 의견을 2쪽 내외의 분량으로 서술하신 뒤에 편집간사에게 email로 보내주시기 바랍니다.

종합평가 및 수정보완 지시, 또는 게재 불가 사유
년 월 일
대학: 성명: